Based on 562 votes and 182 reviews.
I really wanted to like this movie but I feel like I kinda hated it.
This movie was totally ignored by the Academy, and deserves to be seen by a much larger audience. Paul Giamatti, and Dustin Hoffman, give unbelievable performances.
Paul Giamatti's acting is stellar. He is utterly convincing playing his character at a variety of ages. Sure the makeup helps, but he inhabits the character totally.
Another great performance by Hoffman!
Very funny with a very good story
Funny yet poignant
wonderful,wonderful, wonderful
Excellent movie, well acted, but a bit too long in places .... and not really funny; I loved the photography and I loved the complex character of Barney and the others are also so well portrayed ...yet I could not understand why his wife was so unforgiving ... yet never ceased to love him....
Great story great acting and entertaining !!
This movie has it all--Montreal ambience, amazing acting, comedy, tragedy, great characters and a mystery to boot.