Based on 208 votes and 32 reviews.
Andy Garcia puts down the gun and picks up some major kudos for this one. Well acted script dealing with lies and the family that keeps them. Supporting cast is top notch in this very entertaining slice of life.
Not exactly a 'sidesplitter' when it comes to comedy - but it does have it's moments.
Good writing and good performances.
I liked it alot
Just ok
Great comedy in just the right doses. City Island is a relief from all the mediocre (comedy) Hollywood flicks of this year. Andy Garcia is definitely in his element.
Andy Garcia the highlight of this movie.
A funnly look at the workings of a family acted finely by its cast.
it was ok
It is an extremely dead-pan comedy and hilarious. The odd-ball stories of a normal average-day family!! Go see it!!