Based on 172 votes and 38 reviews.
If this movie wins an oscar award, that would be very sad.
What a powerful, emotional movie. The acting was awesome...Oscar deserving!! Definitely a must see!!!
Very emotional and touching.
Sad story, excellent cast...can foresee oscar nominations for best actors and best supporting roles.
it was total let down. i expected it to be much better. the ending was absolutely terrible. a waste of money.
Very powerful Drama. Almost borderline depressing. But still an incredible and well told story. A must see.
Usually, I am very critical about American movies, but this one was one of the best movies I have seen. Definitely in my top 5. It is an original story, not to cliché, that reflect the sad really of soldiers coming back home from wars… Awesome movie !
This movie was very powerful and had a very interesting story line. I would definitely recommend it. The acting was phenomenal! Toby should get an Oscar for his performance because he really did transform himself.
WOW !! What a great movie. A emotional rollercoaster that both sexes will love.The whole cast deserves an oscar for this. Don't listen to any of the negative comments on here, its an incredible movie.
I loved it, totally realistic and full of great dialogue and chemistry between the actors. I just saw E! Channel said “It’s really strong. The casting was brilliant – especially Tobey and Jake as brothers. At first I thought I knew where it was going, and then it took some unexpected turns. I was really impressed.”